The man who cracked the lottery

The man who cracked the lottery

Crime tale: A recounting of the greatest lottery scandal in historical past

The report landed on Rob Sand’s table with one thing lower than a thud. Despite conserving the contents of an investigation nonetheless open after greater than two years, the report was once slightly 1/2 an inch thick. “Happy birthday,” his boss mentioned.

It was once now not Rob Sand’s birthday. His boss, an Iowa deputy lawyer basic named Thomas H. Miller, was once retiring in July 2014 after just about 3 many years of prosecuting the whole lot from homicide to fraud. He employed Sand about 4 years previous and made him the youngest prosecutor in a nine-attorney staff that treated difficult circumstances in every single place the state. Now Miller was once offloading circumstances to colleagues. This one, having to do with a suspicious lottery price ticket value $16.five million, was once stuffed with useless ends. Investigators did not even know if against the law have been dedicated. The maximum tantalizing items of proof have been on a DVD: two grainy surveillance clips from a gasoline station. Sand slid the disc into his pc and pressed play.

A man walked right into a QuikTrip comfort shop simply off Interstate 80 in Des Moines. It was once a weekday afternoon, two days ahead of Christmas. The hood of the man’s black sweatshirt was once pulled over his head, obscuring his face from two surveillance cameras overhead. Under the hoodie, he gave the impression to be dressed in a ball cap; over the hoodie, he wore a black jacket. The man grabbed a fountain drink and two scorching canine.

“Hello!” the cashier mentioned brightly.

The man answered in a low-pitched drawl, a voice that struck Sand as distinct: “Hell-ooooh.”

“Couple hot dogs?” the cashier requested.

“Yes, sir,” the man answered quietly, his head down.

The man pulled two items of paper from his pocket. They have been play slips for Hot Lotto, a Powerball-like lottery sport to be had in 14 states and Washington, D.C. A participant — or the sport’s pc — picked 5 numbers between 1 and 39 after which a 6th quantity, referred to as the Hot Ball, between 1 and 19. The prize for buying the first 5 numbers proper was once $10,000. But a miles better prize that various consistent with the choice of gamers who purchased tickets went to any individual who were given all six numbers proper. The document Hot Lotto jackpot of just about $20 million have been claimed in 2007. The jackpot at the time of this video was once drawing near the document. The said odds of successful it have been one in 10,939,383.

The cashier took the man’s play slips, which had already been stuffed out with more than one units of numbers. At three:24 p.m., the cashier ran the slips thru the lottery terminal. An older man with a cane limped by means of the refrigerated segment. A bus drove by means of. The cashier passed over his exchange. Once out of doors, the man pulled down his hood and got rid of his cap, were given into his S.U.V. and drove away. The gas-station automobile parking space gleamed; there have been snow flurries that afternoon.

Two years into the case, that was once nearly all the investigators had. Sand watched the video over and over, making an attempt to select up each and every little element: the S.U.V.’s make; the man’s vague look: in all probability in his 40s, and 100 kilos obese, perhaps extra; the tenor of his voice.

Sand, a baby-faced Iowan who became down Harvard Law School for the University of Iowa College of Law, had a background that appeared absolute best for the case: a highschool activity writing pc code and doing tech toughen, a strong point in white-collar crime. His contemporary circumstances integrated securities fraud and robbery by means of public officers.

The price ticket in the video was once bought on Dec. 23, 2010. Six days later, the successful Hot Lotto numbers have been decided on: three, 12, 16, 26, 33, 11. The subsequent day, the Iowa Lottery introduced QuikTrip in Des Moines had offered the successful price ticket. But one month after the numbers have been drawn, no person had offered the price ticket.

The Iowa Lottery held a information convention. Phone calls poured in; dozens of folks claimed to be the winner. Some mentioned that they had misplaced the price ticket. Others mentioned it was once stolen from them. But lottery officers had an important proof that wasn’t publicly to be had: the serial quantity on the successful price ticket and the video of the man purchasing it. One by means of one, they crossed off potential claimants. One caller mentioned his buddy was once a standard Hot Lotto participant who had simply died in a automobile smash — must he move to the junkyard to look thru his deceased buddy’s automobile?

Three months after the successful price ticket was once introduced, the lottery issued every other public reminder. Another adopted at six months and once more at 9 months, each and every time caution that winners had 365 days to say their cash. “I was convinced it would never be claimed,” says Mary Neubauer, the Iowa Lottery’s vp of exterior members of the family. Since 1999, she had handled round 200 folks who had received greater than $1 million; she’d by no means observed a successful million-dollar price ticket move unclaimed. “And then comes Nov. 9, 2011.”

A man named Philip Johnston, a legal professional from Quebec, known as the Iowa Lottery and gave Neubauer the proper 15-digit serial quantity on the successful Hot Lotto price ticket. Neubauer requested his age — in his 60s, he mentioned — and what he was once dressed in when he bought the price ticket. His description, a sports activities coat and grey flannel get dressed pants, didn’t fit the QuikTrip video. Then, in a next name, the man admitted he had “fibbed”; he mentioned he was once serving to a shopper declare the price ticket so the consumer would not be known.

This was once towards the Iowa Lottery laws, which require the identities of winners to be public. Johnston floated the risk of chickening out his declare. Neubauer was once suspicious: The winner’s anonymity was once value $16.five million?

One 12 months to the day after the successful numbers popped up on the random-number-generator computer systems — and not more than two hours ahead of the four p.m. time limit — representatives from a outstanding Des Moines legislation company confirmed up at the Iowa Lottery’s headquarters with the successful price ticket. The company was once claiming the price ticket on behalf of a agree with. Later, the Iowa Lottery discovered that the agree with’s beneficiary was once a company in Belize whose president was once Philip Johnston, the Canadian lawyer. “It just absolutely stunk all over the place,” says Terry Rich, leader government of the Iowa Lottery. The Iowa lawyer basic’s workplace and the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation opened a case.

In an interview in Quebec City, Johnston informed investigators that he have been contacted about the price ticket by means of a Houston lawyer named Robert Sonfield. Johnston additionally pointed investigators towards a Sugar Land, Tex., businessman named Robert Rhodes. A go back and forth to Texas by means of Iowa investigators proved fruitless; throughout their a number of days there, each Sonfield and Rhodes controlled to keep away from them.

By the time the report ended up on the table of Rob Sand in 2014, the case had got cultlike standing in his workplace. It was once spoken about with gallows humor: “We’ll find the guy who bought the ticket ended up getting offed,” Sand mentioned. “That’s what this is going to turn out to be, a murder case.”

Miller had mentored Sand and noticed in him a kindred spirit, somebody for whom training legislation was once a calling. Sometimes Sand’s ethical compass was once so stable that he got here off as a sq.; his brothers-in-law nicknamed him Baby Jesus. Sand grew up in Decorah, in northeast Iowa, the son of a small-town physician who nonetheless made space calls. He sought after to get into white-collar legal prosecution as it targeted now not on crimes of desperation however on crimes of greed. “Crimes against gratitude,” Sand known as them.

But all he had was once grainy video of a man purchasing a lottery price ticket value $16.five million. “We only had one bullet left in our revolver,” Sand says, “and that was releasing the video.”

On Oct. nine, 2014, just about 46 months after the man in the hoodie left the QuikTrip, the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation put out a information unlock that integrated a hyperlink to a 74-second clip of the surveillance pictures. A couple of days later, in Maine, an worker of the Maine Lottery opened an e mail forwarded from his boss. The worker known the distinct voice in the video: It belonged to a man who had spent per week in the Maine Lottery places of work a couple of years previous undertaking a safety audit.

In Des Moines, a internet developer at the Iowa Lottery who watched the video additionally known that voice: It belonged to a man she had labored along for years. A receptionist in every other lottery workplace passed her earbuds to Noelle Krueger, a draw supervisor, and informed her to concentrate. “Why am I listening to a video or listening to a tape of Eddie?” Krueger answered.

By Eddie, she intended Eddie Tipton, the information-security director for the Multi-State Lottery Association. The group runs lotteries for 33 other states plus the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands. It was once founded in the Des Moines suburbs. Among the video games it ran was once the Hot Lotto.

EDDIE TIPTON CUT a large, pleasant determine round the workplace of the Multi-State Lottery Association. He grew up in rural Texas, however whilst his siblings have been out of doors, he was once all the time in his room, fiddling together with his pc. He was once a paranoid type who hardly paid with bank cards, who frightened about folks tracing his identification. But he all the time sought after folks to love him. When a co-worker was once in a nasty temper, one colleague mentioned, Tipton would pat him on the shoulder and say, “I just want you to know I’m your friend.”

Tipton constructed a four,800-square-foot, $540,000 space in the cornfields south of Des Moines. The space had 5 bedrooms and an enormous basement, together with a pool desk, a shuffleboard desk, a stadium-style house theater with couches and an area he thought to be changing into a basketball courtroom. Friends questioned why a unmarried man wanted one of these giant space and the way he may just have the funds for it on a wage simply shy of $100,000 a 12 months. In non-public moments, Tipton informed them he was once lonely and sought after a circle of relatives greater than the rest, so he poured his financial savings into the space he was hoping to fill with a spouse and youngsters. But the proper spouse by no means got here. Instead, he hosted workplace Christmas events, and he continuously requested pals to consult with. His circle of relatives, nonetheless in Texas, checked on him steadily.

His existence revolved round his activity. The Multi-State Lottery Association was once a small group, and Tipton felt overextended. He wrote tool and labored on internet pages. He treated community safety and firewalls. And he reviewed safety for lottery video games in just about 3 dozen states. He was once setting up 60-hour weeks and staying at the workplace till 11 p.m.

When Ed Stefan, the leader news officer and leader safety officer at the Multi-State Lottery Association, noticed the surveillance video, he did not wish to imagine it. This wasn’t only a few co-worker. This was once Eddie Tipton, a man he had recognized for greater than twenty years, since they have been in calculus elegance at the University of Houston. Stefan met his long term spouse whilst he and Tipton have been on a charity motorbike journey in Texas; Tipton would later be of their wedding ceremony. Stefan helped Tipton get his activity at the affiliation. They purchased some 50 acres of land in combination and constructed adjoining properties. They even implemented for a joint patent for computer-based lottery safety.

Stefan watched the convenience-store video for the first time after a former co-worker despatched him the hyperlink that have been launched by means of prosecutors. That simply cannot be Eddie, he idea. Then: That’s Eddie. Why is he dressed in a hoodie? I have by no means observed Eddie in a hoodie. Stefan were given in poor health to his abdomen: His buddy, a man with deep wisdom of the computer systems that ran the lottery, was once there onscreen purchasing a price ticket that will be value $16.five million. Later, Stefan would inform investigators it was once like learning your mom was once an ax assassin. He felt betrayed.

Jason Maher was once every other buddy and colleague who did not wish to imagine what he was once seeing on the video. He and Tipton had met at Taki, a Japanese eating place out of doors Des Moines that they each frequented. The lifelong pc aficionados and players take to each other; Tipton joined Maher’s gaming extended family, and so they spent hours enjoying the multiplayer on-line sport World of Tanks. Tipton urged Maher follow for a role at the lottery affiliation as a community engineer. Tipton, Maher informed me, “had a heart of gold.”

So when Maher noticed the video and heard that acquainted low-pitched voice, he did what a pc whiz does. “That night I sat down — there’s no way Eddie did this,” Maher mentioned. “There’s got to be something wrong.” He put the report of the surveillance tape into audio tool, got rid of white noise and remoted the voice. Then he took pictures from safety cameras in his space — Tipton had simply visited the night time ahead of — and in comparison Tipton’s voice in that pictures with the convenience-store video. “It was a complete and utter match, sound wave and everything,” Maher mentioned. The subsequent day, he went to the QuikTrip the place the price ticket was once bought and measured the dimensions of the tiles on the ground, the top of the shelving devices, the distance between the door and the money sign in. He used the effects to match the hand dimension, foot dimension and top of the man in the video with the man he had turn into pals with.

“When the F.B.I. guys came in, I wanted to be able to tell them it wasn’t Eddie,” Maher mentioned. “Once I did this, it was like, ‘Well, [expletive] — it’s Eddie.’ ”

IN NOVEMBER 2014, state investigators confirmed up at Tipton’s workplace. They requested him whom he knew in Houston. He informed them about his circle of relatives — mom, sister and brothers, together with Tommy, a former sheriff’s deputy became justice of the peace close to the Texas Hill Country. He didn’t point out Robert Rhodes, the man who to start with handed the $16.five million price ticket to an lawyer. By looking out Tipton’s RelatedIn profile, investigators discovered that Tipton have been hired at Rhodes’s Texas-based tool corporate, Systems Evolution, for 6 years as its leader operations officer. In truth, the two have been highest pals and vacationed in combination.

Tipton was once arrested in January 2015 and charged with two prison counts of fraud. Half a 12 months later, on a scorching, sticky July morning, Rob Sand stood ahead of a jury at the Polk County Courthouse. “This is a classic story about an inside job,” he started. “A man who by virtue of his employment is not allowed to play the lottery, nor allowed to win, buys a lottery ticket, wins and passes the ticket along to friends to be claimed by someone unconnected to him. This story, though, has a 21st-century twist.”

The prosecution knew Tipton had purchased the successful price ticket. The video, in particular the distinct voice that colleagues had known, made that lovely transparent. So did mobile phone information, which confirmed Tipton was once on the town that day, now not out of city for the vacations as he claimed, and that he have been on the telephone for 71 mins with Robert Rhodes, the man who in brief had ownership of the price ticket. Investigators believed he’d mounted the lottery. But how?

Jason Maher, Tipton’s gaming pal, informed them about Tipton’s hobby in rootkits: malicious tool that may be put in by the use of flash pressure with the intention to take keep watch over of a pc whilst protecting its life till it deletes itself later. Sand theorized that Tipton went into the draw room six weeks ahead of the giant jackpot and, regardless of the presence of 2 colleagues, controlled to insert a thumb pressure into considered one of the two computer systems that make a choice the successful numbers. That thumb pressure contained the rootkit; the rootkit allowed Tipton to direct which numbers would win the Hot Lotto on Dec. 29, 2010.

Tipton’s protection lawyer, Dean Stowers, known as this the “Mission: Impossible” idea. Stowers characterised the tale of a malicious, self-destructing rootkit (“magic software”), put in whilst two colleagues seemed on, as preposterous. His final arguments referenced a citation attributed to Albert Einstein: “Logic will get you from A to B. Imagination will take you anywhere.”

But Sand known as Stowers’s center of attention in this difficult rootkit idea a purple herring. Sand informed the jury to concentrate on the some ways Tipton may have mounted the lottery: He wrote the code. He had get admission to to the random-number-generator machines ahead of they have been shipped to different states. You should not have to know the precise era to convict Tipton, Sand argued; you simply have to comprehend the near-impossible accident of the lottery safety leader’s purchasing a successful price ticket and that price ticket’s being handed to his highest buddy. The prosecution needed to turn out simplest that Tipton attempted to illegally purchase lottery tickets as a Multi-State Lottery Association worker and attempted to say the prize thru fraudulent approach.

The jury discovered him responsible on July 20, 2015. He can be sentenced to 10 years in jail, and he would attraction. The State Supreme Court later disregarded his conviction on one fee, tampering with lottery apparatus, and the case was once despatched again to District Court.

Six weeks after the trial concluded, Sand had returned to his table. It have been a hectic summer time. But in the again of his thoughts, he was once nonetheless fascinated by Eddie Tipton. Sand knew white-collar criminals are not normally stuck on their first try. The proven fact that Tipton’s lawyer had demanded a 90-day fast trial, an odd maneuver that lower brief the prosecution’s time to analyze, made Sand suspicious. His intestine mentioned different fraudulent lottery tickets have been available in the market.

One morning Sand’s workplace telephone rang, and a space code he known popped up: 281, from Texas, the place Tipton used to reside. Sand picked up. The caller had a drawl and informed Sand he’d observed a piece of writing in the La Grange, Tex., newspaper about Tipton’s conviction. “Did y’all know,” the tipster requested, “that Eddie’s brother Tommy Tipton won the lottery, maybe about 10 years back?”

RICHARD RENNISON’S telephone rang at the F.B.I. workplace in Texas City, a port city on the shore of Galveston Bay. Sand was once on the line, inquiring a couple of case that Rennison, a unique agent for the bureau, investigated a decade ahead of. At the time, it became out to be not anything. But the case nonetheless caught in Rennison’s thoughts. “Hey,” Rennison answered, “that’s my Bigfoot case.”

A man named Tom Bargas had contacted native law-enforcement government in early 2006 with a suspicious tale. Bargas owned 44 fireworks stands in Texas. Twice a 12 months — after the Fourth of July and after New Year’s — he needed to care for monumental quantities of money, greater than a half-million bucks directly. An area justice of the peace who shod Bargas’s horses known as him round New Year’s. The justice of the peace stuck Bargas off guard: “I got half a million in cash that I want to swap with your money.” “What’s wrong with your money?” Bargas answered.

What’s a justice of the peace who makes round $35,000 a 12 months doing with that a lot money? Bargas idea. He known as the sheriff and the police, who known as the F.B.I. Soon, the bureau contacted Bargas. Federal brokers geared up him with a cord. Bargas met with the man, who pulled out a briefcase full of $450,000 in money, nonetheless of their Federal Reserve wrappers. As the F.B.I. listened, Bargas swapped $100,000 of worn, circulated expenses for $100,000 of the man’s crisp, unused expenses. To the F.B.I., this smelled like public corruption, and so they went to paintings investigating the serial numbers on the expenses.

One day a few months later, Rennison were given a choice from the Fayette County sheriff in La Grange, a spot highest recognized for the Chicken Ranch, the brothel that impressed “The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas.” The sheriff was once guffawing so laborious he may just hardly ever discuss. He informed Rennison the justice of the peace was once holed up in a Houston medical institution with two shattered legs. He had fallen 31 toes out of a tree. He have been looking Bigfoot.

“My grandmother was raised on a farm in Arkansas where this creature would come in and harass all the farm animals,” this man later informed investigators. “My grandmother would tell me all these stories of this animal that harassed my family.” He went on: “I started hitting the woods. It was always that doubt in your mind. And then something happened to me in Louisiana where I actually watched these animals for a couple of hours, and I’ve been hooked ever since.”

Rennison visited the man in the medical institution after which arrange an interview as soon as he was once discharged. The man was once a member of the Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization. He informed Rennison he’d received the lottery in Colorado whilst on a Bigfoot hunt. He was once on the outs together with his spouse and was once looking to stay the lottery winnings from her. A Bigfoot-hunting buddy claimed the prize in change for 10 p.c of the cash. It all looked at. Case closed.

“Right before I leave, we’re still sitting down at this nice conference table, and he looks over at his attorneys and says, ‘Can I show him?’ ” Rennison recalled. “Hanging off the back of his chair is a plastic grocery bag. He pulls out a plaster cast of a footprint.”

Rennison put the footprint subsequent to his personal foot. They have been more or less the identical dimension. “That doesn’t look like Bigfoot,” the F.B.I. agent mentioned. “It was a juvenile,” the man snapped. The man’s identify was once Tommy Tipton.

NOW THE HUNT was once on for extra illicitly claimed tickets. Iowa investigators spotted that the buddy who claimed the $568,990 Colorado Lottery prize for Tommy Tipton, a man named Alexander Hicks, was once useless. “We first thought, Whoa — this is our first body related to this case,” Sand says. It wasn’t. Hicks had died of most cancers.

The investigators gathered a decade’s value of winners from lotteries round the nation related to the Multi-State Lottery Association. They loaded information from roughly 45,000 successful tickets into Microsoft Excel spreadsheets and looked for any connections to Eddie Tipton. They reviewed Tipton’s Facebook pals, pulled telephone information and seemed for suits with the spreadsheet.

In September 2015, they discovered $783,257.72 payout for Wisconsin’s Very Own Megabucks Game have been claimed in early 2008 by means of a Texas man named Robert Rhodes, who sought after to deposit it into the account of a limited-liability company. That drawing happened on Dec. 29, 2007 — the identical day the successful numbers on Tipton’s $16.five million Iowa price ticket have been decided on 3 years later. Rhodes was once Eddie Tipton’s highest buddy. Another hit.

One night over the vacations, Sand was once at his folks’ space operating on his pc, sifting thru information, the use of seek instructions on his pc over and over. He spotted Kyle Conn from Hemphill, Tex., received a $644,478 jackpot in the Oklahoma Lottery some years again. Tommy Tipton had 3 Facebook pals named Conn. Sand were given a listing of imaginable telephone numbers for a Kyle Conn and cross-referenced them with Tommy Tipton’s mobile phone information. Another hit.

Investigators spotted two successful Kansas Lottery tickets for $15,402 apiece have been bought on Dec. 23, 2010 — the identical day Tipton had bought the Iowa price ticket, and the identical day that mobile phone information indicated he was once riding thru Kansas on the strategy to Texas for the vacations. One of the successful tickets was once claimed by means of a Texan named Christopher McCoulskey, the different by means of an Iowa girl named Amy Warrick. Each was once a chum of Eddie Tipton’s.

Early one morning, Sand and an investigator knocked on the girl’s door. She informed them she’d long gone on one date with Tipton, however their dating changed into platonic. Tipton informed her he wasn’t in a position to say a successful lottery price ticket on account of his activity. If she may just declare it, Tipton mentioned, she may just stay a good portion as a present for her contemporary engagement.

“You have these honest dupes,” Sand says. “All these people are being offered thousands of dollars for doing something that’s a little bit sneaky but not illegal.” Investigators in Iowa now had six tickets they figured have been a part of a larger rip-off. But the query remained: How did it paintings?

Investigators in Wisconsin came upon they nonetheless had the random-number-generator computer systems used for the 2007 jackpot sitting in garage. Unlike Iowa’s computer systems, the laborious drives had now not been cleaned; their tool was once the identical as the day Robert Rhodes received $783,257.72. Wisconsin enlisted a pc professional named Sean McLinden to habits an investigation that integrated forensic research and opposite engineering.

On Jan. 7, 2016, Sand’s telephone rang. It was once David Maas, an assistant lawyer basic in Wisconsin. He informed Sand to test his e mail. Maas had despatched him an attachment with 21 strains of “pseudocode,” a common-language translation of McLinden’s forensic research that confirmed a part of Tipton’s malicious pc code. The code was once sufficiently small that it might now not seriously change the dimension of the report, which would possibly create suspicion. And the code hadn’t been hidden. You simply had to know what to search for.

“This,” Maas says, “was finding the smoking gun.”

The smoking gun would assist result in a responsible plea from Tipton. In the plea deal, Sand insisted that Tipton come blank about how he mounted the lottery. This may just assist the lottery business enhance its safety. If Tipton lied — or if every other fraudulent price ticket have been discovered later — the deal can be voided, and Tipton can be matter to additional fees.

Tipton’s program was once known as QVRNG.dll: Quantum Vision Random Number Generator. In Tipton’s telling, his wasn’t an evil plan to get wealthy. This was once simply a pc nerd’s try to crack the machine. “It was never my intent to start a full-out ticket scam,” Tipton informed investigators. “It occurred to me, like, Wow, I could do this, I could be making a living doing this.” He went on: “If this was, like, some mob-related thing, I’d just give this information to the mob and they would go out and win the lotteries left and right. Nobody would know. But that — I don’t have any mob ties. I don’t know anybody. I gave tickets to friends or family.”

More than a decade in the past, Tipton informed them, he walked previous considered one of the group’s accountants at the Multi-State Lottery Association. Tipton was once conservative, the accountant liberal, and so they frequently ribbed each and every different.

“Hey, did you put your secret numbers in there?” the accountant mentioned, teasing Tipton.

“What do you mean?”

“Well, you know, you can set numbers on any given day since you wrote the software.”

And that is when the thought first got here. “Just like a little seed that was planted,” Tipton mentioned in his proffer. “And then during one slow period I just had a — had a thought that it’s possible, and I tried it and I put it in.” The code wasn’t a brazen “Mission: Impossible” stunt of sneaking into the draw room with a malicious thumb pressure. It was once a easy piece of code, partially copied from an web supply, inserted by means of the one man answerable for news safety at a company that runs 3 dozen United States lotteries.

Here’s how the Multi-State Lottery Association’s random-number turbines have been meant to paintings: The pc takes a studying from a Geiger counter that measures radiation in the surrounding air, in particular the radioactive isotope Americium-241. The studying is expressed as a protracted choice of code; that quantity provides the generator its true randomness. The random quantity is known as the seed, and the seed is plugged into the set of rules, a pseudorandom quantity generator known as the Mersenne Twister. At the finish, the pc spits out the successful lottery numbers.

Tipton’s further strains of code first checked to look if the coming lottery drawing fulfilled Tipton’s slender instances. It needed to be on a Wednesday or a Saturday night, and considered one of 3 dates in a nonleap 12 months: the 147th day of the 12 months (May 27), the 327th day (Nov. 23) or the 363rd day (Dec. 29). Investigators spotted the ones dates normally fell round vacations — Memorial Day, Thanksgiving and Christmas — when Tipton was once frequently on holiday. If the ones standards have been happy, the random-number generator was once diverted to another monitor. Instead, the set of rules would use a predetermined seed quantity that limited the pool of possible successful numbers to a way smaller, predictable set of numbers.

So Tipton knew what no person else knew: For the Iowa Hot Lotto drawing on Dec. 29, 2010, there were not actually 10,939,383 units of imaginable successful numbers. There have been only some hundred. Late at night time ahead of a draw that fulfilled his standards, Tipton stayed in his messy, computer-filled workplace. He set a take a look at pc to the date and time of the coming draw, and he ran the program time and again. For the first lottery he rigged, the Nov. 23, 2005, drawing in Colorado, Tipton wrote down each and every possible set of successful numbers on a yellow criminal pad. He passed the pad — each and every sheet had 35 or so units of six numbers — to his brother.

It was once a cheat sheet; as an alternative of enjoying each and every imaginable quantity mixture to verify one mixture received, he needed to play only some hundred. “If you want a chance to win, you need to play all of these,” Tipton informed his brother. “I don’t know if any of them will win, but you’re going anyway” — his brother was once about to head on a Bigfoot-hunting go back and forth to Colorado — and “those have an excellent chance of successful in accordance with my research.

“Play them,” he said. “Play all of them.”

ON A CLEAR, BLUE summer time day in Des Moines ultimate 12 months, Eddie Tipton, a square-shaped, balding man who was once then 54, trudged up the stairs of the Polk County Courthouse. He wore bluejeans and a short-sleeved salmon-colored button-up blouse, untucked and unbuttoned, with a blue T-shirt beneath. His palms have been shoved in his wallet, and his head was once down. He had accredited a plea settlement for masterminding the biggest lottery rip-off in American historical past: one depend of ongoing legal habits, a part of a bundle deal that allowed his brother to be sentenced to simply 75 days. Tipton was once right here for his sentencing.

In statements to prosecutors, Tipton painted himself in the maximum beneficiant approach imaginable, one of those coding Robin Hood, stealing from the lottery and serving to folks in want: his brother who had 5 daughters, his buddy who’d simply gotten engaged. “I did not actually want the cash,” Tipton mentioned. The pass judgement on famous that Tipton gave the impression to rationalize his movements — that Tipton did not suppose it was once essentially unlawful, only a making the most of a hollow in the lottery’s machine. It wasn’t all that other, Tipton believed, from insider buying and selling, excluding rules did not in particular limit him from fidgeting with the random-number-generator code. His lawyer equated what he did with counting playing cards at a on line casino. Tipton wasn’t robbing the on line casino at gunpoint; he was once dishonest the space.

The different aspect disagreed. Tipton was once “not anything however a ordinary thief who came about to be passed the keys to the sweet shop,” Miller, Sand’s former boss, told me. “It’s now not a case of Sherlock Holmes’s archnemesis, Moriarty, being a legal genius. This is simply a standard schlub, who is a thief who occurs to have wisdom of pc safety.”

From Tipton’s standpoint, it was once difficult. He had executed one thing to look if he may just do it. To his wonder, it labored. He mentioned he inserted that code simplest as soon as; after the code was once licensed by means of Gaming Laboratories International, machines containing it have been shipped in every single place the nation. He had created a beast and despatched it into the international. “You plant that cash tree for your yard,” as Maas, the Wisconsin prosecutor, put it, “and it is laborious to not stay selecting at it.”

In interviews, investigators had requested Tipton if he was once happy with the good fortune of his code. “It was once extra like I am in a position for it to be long gone,” Tipton said. “It was once by no means my intent to head available in the market and get started successful these kind of lotteries. It was once simply, like I mentioned, step-by-step it came about.”

At sentencing, the pass judgement on requested if Tipton had the rest to mention. After a protracted pause, Tipton cleared his throat. Family participants and previous co-workers have been in the court docket. “Well,” Tipton said matter-of-factly, “I indisputably remorseful about my movements. It’s tough to mention that with all the folks at the back of me that I harm. And I remorseful about it. I am sorry.” As the case was once being litigated, Tipton had confessed to pals that he was once racked with guilt. At every other level throughout the lawsuits, Tipton leaned throughout a divide and prolonged his hand to Sand. Sand took the handshake as an indication of recognize, as though Tipton had idea he outsmarted the machine however the machine figured him out. On the day of his sentencing, Tipton informed the pass judgement on he’d been taking categories to enter ministry. A deputy positioned Tipton in handcuffs and led him away.

Earlier in the summer time, Tipton sat in a convention room with Sand and law-enforcement and lottery officers to offer his complete confession, as promised in his plea settlement. Eventually he would head to Clarinda Correctional Facility in southern Iowa, close to the Missouri border, the place he stays as of late, Offender No. 6832975. (Through his lawyer, he declined interview requests for this text; Tipton didn’t reply to just about a dozen emails thru the jail e mail machine.)

During a lunch spoil in Tipton’s hourslong confession, Sand and others curious about the prosecution walked a couple of blocks to the High Life Lounge. They ordered bacon-wrapped tater children to have a good time. “Eddie sees himself as a lot brighter than the remainder of the international, the sharpest instrument in the toolbox,” Sand says. “It’s the roughly factor I see in white-collar case after white-collar case, folks who suppose they are higher than everyone else, that folks agree with them and love them, and that no person will be capable to determine this out.”

The pass judgement on sentenced Tipton to a most of 25 years in jail. His restitution bills to the more than a few state lotteries got here to $2.2 million although, consistent with his lawyer, Tipton pocketed simplest round $350,000 from the rip-off, the leisure going to these who claimed the tickets. (Prosecutors didn’t imagine that, pointing to Tipton’s huge space in addition to the proven fact that Tipton and his brother owned 11 items of belongings both collectively or for my part in Fayette County, Tex.) In Iowa, which has indeterminate sentencing, a 25-year sentence may just imply Tipton is launched a lot faster; Sand expects Tipton to be launched by means of the Iowa Board of Parole inside of seven years.

Sand says he felt a deep highbrow delight in fixing the puzzle: “The justice machine at its highest is actually a couple of seek for fact.” But it couldn’t go back in time and correct wrongs. At the end of this yearslong case, he came to a realization: He had grown weary of dealing with criminals. “In such a lot darkness,” Sand says, “I began to lose my gentle.”

A couple of months after the highest-profile case of his occupation, Sand went as much as his boss and give up. He had determined to run for state auditor in the coming November election, so he may just make sure adjustments. If he wins, he’s going to be investigating executive waste, abuse and fraud. “There’s no approach I might make a transfer to break out from the darkness of prosecution with out completing this situation first,” Sand says. “So completing it, to me, was once now not simply enjoyable. It was once freeing.”

Timeline of the greatest crime in US lottery historical past

The following is a compilation of Lottery Post information protection chronicling the Hot Lotto thriller and therefore came upon crime.

We get started the timeline with a information tale indicating that simplest three months remained for the $16 million Hot Lotto jackpot to be claimed.



  • Iowa Lottery safety leader bent on figuring out identification of jackpot winner, Jan. 10, 2012
  • NY legal professional in lottery thriller travels to Iowa this week, Jan. 17, 2012
  • Iowa Lottery safety leader to grill NY legal professional over Hot Lotto price ticket, Jan. 17, 2012
  • Representative of Hot Lotto winner named in lawsuit, Jan. 20, 2012
  • Hot Lotto agree with consultant would possibly not identify winner, Jan. 20, 2012
  • Iowa Lottery threatens to disclaim jackpot payout if winner remains nameless, Jan. 23, 2012
  • Lawyer provides up $14 million Iowa lottery price ticket declare, Jan. 26, 2012
  • $14.three million Hot Lotto prize declare withdrawn, Jan. 27, 2012
  • Iowa Legislators happy with Lottery’s dealing with of puzzle jackpot winner, Feb. 1, 2012
  • Iowa Lottery to offer away thousands and thousands from jackpot thriller, Feb. 26, 2012
  • Iowa Lottery director: 50-50 that Hot Lotto thriller will probably be solved, Aug. nine, 2012
  • Iowa officers looking to resolve lotto thriller, might unlock surveillance video, Aug. 19, 2012




  • MUSL worker arrested in Hot Lotto jackpot thriller, Jan. 15, 2015
  • BOMBSHELL: MUSL worker would possibly have rigged Hot Lotto automatic drawing, Apr. 13, 2015
  • Texas man charged in Iowa lottery case contests extradition, Apr. 20, 2015
  • Extradition trial starts this week in $16.5M Hot Lotto fraud case, Jun. 7, 2015
  • Inside the greatest lottery rip-off ever, Jul. 7, 2015
  • Trial underway in international’s greatest lottery fraud case, Jul. 14, 2015
  • Lottery safety leader: Rigging automatic sport “unfortunately” imaginable, Jul. 15, 2015
  • Prosecution rests in Hot Lotto trial, Jul. 16, 2015
  • Defense temporarily wraps up in Hot Lotto trial, Jul. 16, 2015
  • Hot Lotto case strikes to jury for deliberations, Jul. 17, 2015
  • Former lottery safety worker responsible of rigging $14.3M drawing, Jul. 20, 2015
  • MUSL safety employee who rigged drawing will get 10 years, Sep. nine, 2015
  • Texas government had up to now investigated brother of lottery cheat, Oct. 14, 2015
  • Another $1.2M Hot Lotto jackpot rigged by means of Tipton, officers say, Nov. 21, 2015
  • Jackpot-fixing investigation expands to extra state lotteries, Dec. 18, 2015
  • Prosecutors say Tipton rigged two jackpots he bought tickets for in Kansas, Dec. 21, 2015
  • Maine provides names of Hot Lotto winners to Iowa staff having a look into rigging scheme, Dec. 23, 2015
  • S.C. Lottery assures public no automatic drawings utilized in state, Dec. 23, 2015
  • Kansas lottery gamers wondering sport’s integrity, Dec. 23, 2015
  • Lottery scandal not going to have an effect on New Mexico, professional says, Dec. 26, 2015
  • Tipton granted lengthen in subsequent trial till July, Dec. 29, 2015


  • Iowa Lottery CEO Terry Rich to reply to lottery participant questions reside Monday night, Jan. 11, 2016
  • First lawsuit in state lottery-fixing scandal seeks thousands and thousands, Feb. four, 2016
  • MUSL seeks to brush aside lawsuit over rigged jackpot, Apr. 1, 2016
  • Lottery scammer’s brother dealing with legal fees, Apr. 6, 2016
  • Investigators in finding Tipton’s tool code to rig automatic lottery drawings, Apr. 7, 2016
  • Lottery rigging scandal activates safety audit in South Dakota, Apr. 13, 2016
  • Preliminary listening to rescheduled for Tommy Tipton in lottery rigging case, Apr. 22, 2016
  • Third suspect surrenders in nationwide lottery rigging scandal, Apr. 28, 2016
  • Lottery rip-off investigation involves Tennessee, May 11, 2016
  • Investigators in finding every other buddy of Tipton who cashed rigged lottery prize, May 11, 2016
  • Convicted automatic drawing fraudster argues Iowa courtroom attraction, Jun. 16, 2016
  • US Senate panel calls for information in lottery scandal, Jun. 22, 2016
  • Lottery rigging trial to be moved out of Des Moines, Jun. 27, 2016
  • Eddie Tipton’s new trial not on time till 2017, Jul. 1, 2016
  • Iowa courtroom reverses a part of Tipton’s lottery fraud conviction, Jul. 28, 2016
  • Internal investigation concludes Tipton acted on my own to rig lottery drawings, Aug. 10, 2016
  • Prosecutors say 2 extra males could also be connected to lottery riggings, Aug. 24, 2016
  • Judge: winner’s lawsuit in lottery-fixing case can proceed, Oct. 13, 2016
  • Alleged lottery scandal conspirator to go into new plea, Nov. 14, 2016
  • Accused lottery rigger Eddie Tipton dealing with new Wisconsin fees, Dec. 22, 2016


  • Man information lawsuit over rigged lottery jackpots, Jan. four, 2017
  • Trials for Tipton brothers charged in lottery scandal not on time, Jan. eight, 2017
  • Former MUSL professional gained severance amid lottery jackpot scandal, Jan. 10, 2017
  • Texas man pleads responsible to fraud in lottery scandal case, Jan. 11, 2017
  • Iowa Supreme Court hears lottery rigging case, Feb. 14, 2017
  • Kansas information lawsuit towards accused lottery rigger, Mar. 16, 2017
  • Best buddy to testify towards Tipton at July lottery rigging trial, Mar. 31, 2017
  • Mastermind of lottery fraud will give an explanation for how he rigged jackpots, Jun. 12, 2017
  • FBI overlooked rigged jackpot in 2006 ahead of lottery scheme grew, Jun. 19, 2017
  • The five lottery jackpots Tipton and his pals stole, Jun. 20, 2017
  • Lottery jackpot rigger’s Iowa convictions disregarded, Jun. 23, 2017
  • IT’S OFFICIAL: Tipton pleads responsible to rigging automatic lottery drawings, Jun. 29, 2017
  • Lottery rigging companion used Wisconsin payout for offshore tax rip-off, Jul. 6, 2017
  • Hot Lotto multi-state lottery sport to finish in October, Aug. nine, 2017
  • Lottery rigging mastermind sentenced to 25 years in jail, Aug. 22, 2017
  • Winner sues Colorado Lottery 12 years after rigged drawing, Oct. five, 2017


Updated: May 3, 2018 — 11:50 pm

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *